top of page

Gluten Free/Dairy Free/Vegan/Sugar Free options are available in most flavors.
Call us and we will make you a yummy pie that you can eat!

*Please note that we require 48 hours notice for pie orders*
 

Untitled (Twitter Post) (1).png

9" Whole Pies

Browned-Butter Pecan.png
Browned Butter Pecan

Gooey and chock full of pecan buttery goodness

$42.00
E6F4A251-D398-44C7-BEFF-BA349522CB5A_edited_edited.jpg
Apple Crumble

Loaded with spiced apples with an oatmeal crumb top, also available with a double-crusted top

$42.00
Keylime 2_edited.jpg
Key Lime

Tangy lime filling made with fresh lime juice and zest in a graham cracker crust & topped with fresh whipped cream & zest 

$40.00
DSC_7618_edited_edited.jpg
Erin's Peanut Butter Dream

Our most popular pie! Fluffy peanut butter cream cheese filling in an Oreo crust & topped with chocolate ganache and peanut butter cups!

$40.00
Triple Berry good_edited_edited.jpg
Triple Berry

A melody of red raspberries, sweet strawberries, and plump blueberries with a crumb top. Also available with a double-crusted top.

$42.00
Cherry_edited.jpg
Banana Cream (Best)_edited_edited.jpg
Banana Cream

Perfectly ripe bananas layered between creamy banana pudding & topped with fresh whipped cream (Please Note: A 5 day notice is required for this pie)

$40.00
Chocolate Cream_edited_edited_edited.jpg
Chocolate Cream

Rich chocolate pudding made with bittersweet chocolate in an Oreo crust & topped with fresh whipped cream

$40.00 
Coconut_edited_edited.jpg
Coconut Cream

Thick coconut custard filling in a buttery crust & topped with fresh whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes

​

$40.00

Tangy pieces of fresh local rhubarb mixed with juicy sweet strawberries. A very popular seasonal delight. (Seasonal May-October)

$45.00

Additional Specialty & Gourmet  : Ube, Blueberry Crumb Top, Kahlua Fudge Brownie, Espresso Chocolate Cream, Mississippi Mud, Shoofly, Strawberry Rhubarb, S'more, Grasshopper (Mint Oreo), Cookies & Cream, Mimosa, Chocolate Coffee Stout, Cherry Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Haupia and many more! 

Straw Rhubarb_edited.jpg
Strawberry Rhubarb
Sweet-tart Cherry

A mix of plump sweet cherries and tart cherries.

$42.00

Sunny Sky Pies

446 S. Link Lane

Fort Collins, CO 80524 

(970) 294-1877

bottom of page